top of page

Why Can't an EV Just Be a Good Car?

Oct 29
10 min read

Part 2 of 3: When Disagreement Becomes Ignorance



I have a question that shouldn't be particularly controversial. Why can't an electric vehicle just be a good car?


Why does every conversation about EVs eventually turn into something bigger than the vehicle itself? Why can't someone buy an EV because they like the technology, enjoy the driving experience, or appreciate never having to visit a gas station? And why can't someone else decide an EV isn't right for them without having to defend that decision?


These days, conversations about transportation have become a referendum on intelligence, environmental responsibility, and enthusiasm for the future. That's an awful lot of baggage to attach to something with four wheels and a little mirror so you can check your nose hairs.


In Part 1, I discussed how EV statistics often answer questions that prospective buyers aren't actually asking. This time, I want to explore something I've noticed in discussions with EV enthusiasts: the tendency to treat disagreement as evidence that someone doesn't understand the technology.

And I have some firsthand experience with that.


I've Actually Driven the Damn Things

One argument I keep hearing is that skeptical people just need to drive an EV. The assumption is that a few minutes behind the wheel will clear up whatever misunderstanding is keeping them from buying one.

Well, I've rented a Tesla Model S through Turo twice, a week each time, and a Ford (Mustang) Mach-E for another week. That's three weeks of driving EVs, not a 20-minute joyride with a salesman telling me how wonderful everything is.


And I liked the Tesla! Enough to rent one a second time. It was fun to drive, and I was particularly impressed with how Tesla handled charging. The car knew where the Superchargers were, figured out when I needed to stop, estimated how long I'd be there, and prepared the battery along the way. That's useful software ingenuity, not just another gadget to impress somebody in the passenger seat.


I experienced range anxiety, and I didn’t particularly enjoy sitting at charging stations. But Tesla had clearly put some thought into making the experience manageable.


Then there was the Ford (Mustang) Mach-E.


First, I still consider it an insult to the Mustang name that Ford slapped it on what looks like a soccer-mom Barbie car. I've always associated Mustangs with American muscle, not a family crossover with a horse badge. The Mustang logo projected onto the pavement didn't change my opinion, but that is my hang-up.


The interior didn't impress me, I didn't particularly enjoy driving it, and the charging experience was a step backward. The owner actually recommended I use an iPhone app to find charging stations because the vehicle's navigation couldn't reliably distinguish between charging levels.


Think about that. I'm renting an electric vehicle in an unfamiliar city, and the owner is telling me to use my phone to figure out where I can charge the damn thing. Tesla had already demonstrated that this didn't need to be so complicated.


I didn't walk away thinking EVs were stupid or unreliable. I walked away thinking Tesla had figured out some things that Ford hadn't, at least in the vehicles I rented. And despite enjoying the Tesla enough to rent it twice, I still wasn't convinced I needed to buy one.


Did I Test-Drive Them the Wrong Way?

Someone suggested that renting an EV in an unfamiliar city isn't a particularly good way to evaluate one.

Really? Three separate weeklong rentals gave me time to drive, navigate unfamiliar roads, find public charging stations, and deal with things that don't come up on a quick drive with an EV salesperson. I'd argue that's a hell of a lot more informative than a 20-minute test drive.


It's fair to say a rental doesn't replicate everyday ownership, especially when you can charge at home. I've repeatedly said home charging is one of the biggest advantages of owning an EV, especially if you have a solar system. But I wasn't testing what it's like to plug into my own garage every night. I was testing what it's like to actually use these vehicles away from home.


Pointing out the limits of my experience is fair. Suggesting the experience doesn't count because it wasn't conducted under ideal conditions is not. I wasn't trying to prove EVs were bad. I wanted to see what they were like, and I learned a lot. However…


… apparently, there's a right way to experience an EV, and I missed the memo.


When Disagreement Becomes a Knowledge Problem

Spend enough time reading EV discussions on LinkedIn, or other platforms, and you'll notice a pattern.

Someone raises a concern about price, charging, range, or practicality. Instead of asking about that person's circumstances, somebody immediately responds with statistics, studies, or an explanation of why the concern isn't as significant as they think.


Sometimes those finer points are justified. There is plenty of misinformation about EVs (on both sides), and some people are determined to believe things that simply aren't true. I could pull out my Psychology 101 book and dive into this, but that’s not really the point of this.


But there's an important distinction between correcting misinformation and trying to correct someone's preferences. If someone believes an EV can't travel more than 50 miles without charging, that's a factual misunderstanding worth addressing. If someone understands the capabilities of an EV and still doesn't want one, what exactly needs correcting?


I've seen discussions where people who haven't purchased an EV are characterized as resistant to change, emotionally attached to combustion engines, or unfamiliar with the technology. Maybe some are. But there is a possibility that others have evaluated their options and reached a perfectly reasonable conclusion that differs from yours. That possibility seems weirdly difficult for some people to accept.


My Truck Still Works Just Fine

I've spent almost 20 years working with solar, batteries, and energy technology. I've written a book about residential energy systems, and I understand the advantages of electrification.


I'm not opposed to electric vehicles. I think the technology is impressive, and I can absolutely see why someone would choose one. I've even considered the Rivian R1T and Ford F-150 Lightning because they are badass vehicles.


But I currently drive a 2018 Chevy Colorado 4WD. It's paid off. It runs well. It tows my boat. And it does everything I need a vehicle to do. That doesn't make it superior to an EV. It makes it suitable for me.

If I replaced it with an electric truck, I'd gain some advantages and accept some compromises. Whether those tradeoffs are worthwhile is a decision I get to make. And here's what seems to cause trouble in some of these conversations: I can recognize every advantage an EV offers and still decide buying one isn't worth it for me right now.


I don't need another spreadsheet explaining how much money I might save on gasoline. I understand operating costs. I also understand that replacing a paid-off vehicle with an expensive new one has financial consequences. I struggle to justify spending $100k on my dream EV just to save ~$100 a month on gas.

More importantly, I don't need somebody else deciding which of those considerations should matter most to me.


The International EV Victory Lap

Another thing I've noticed is how frequently EV discussions turn into contests.


Spend enough time on LinkedIn (or other sites), and you'll see the same statistics making the rounds. Norway is approaching 100% EV sales. China is selling more EVs than ever. Europe is embracing electrification. And now we're seeing posts celebrating EV adoption in places like Nepal and Ethiopia.

The numbers are impressive. According to the International Energy Agency, EVs accounted for roughly 97% of new car sales in Norway in 2025, nearly 55% in China, and 28% in Europe. Globally, about one in four new vehicles sold was electric.


Cool story, bro.


I'm not disputing the numbers. I'm questioning what they're supposed to prove to someone deciding what vehicle to buy in the United States.


We've discussed Norway before. It's a relatively small country that has spent years using tax policies and incentives to encourage EV adoption. China has its own mix of industrial policy, incentives, manufacturing capacity, and increasingly affordable EVs. Europe has regulations and market conditions that differ considerably from ours.


These are legitimate examples of how EV adoption can grow under different circumstances. They're worth studying.


But for fuck's sake, Norway has roughly Colorado's population, and Nepal is about the size of Iowa, though it crams nearly 30 million people into that space. These countries have different economies, geography, infrastructure, and transportation needs than the United States. I'm not dismissing their EV adoption numbers, but what am I supposed to do with that information? Sell my truck because somebody in Oslo bought a Tesla?


I've tried responding with facts and reasonable arguments. I'm starting to think a different approach might work better.


South Park Called This One Years Ago

Remember the South Park episode "Smug Alert!" where Gerald buys a hybrid and becomes absolutely insufferable about it?


The joke wasn't that hybrid vehicles were bad. It was that Gerald couldn't simply enjoy driving one. He had to make sure everyone knew he was doing his part to save the planet, while looking down on people who hadn't followed his example. The resulting cloud of smugness became an environmental hazard of its own.


That episode aired in 2006, long before today's EV arguments took over LinkedIn. And every time I read another post suggesting that people who haven't embraced EVs are uninformed, resistant to progress, or somehow less responsible, I think of Gerald.


There's a certain smugness in some of these discussions that's hard to ignore. It's not enough to enjoy the car or explain why it works for you. It suggests that choosing an EV shows better judgment, greater awareness, or a more enlightened outlook than people still driving gasoline-powered vehicles.


And if someone doesn't agree, they just need more education. I don't think most EV owners behave this way. Plenty of people buy EVs because they like the vehicles, enjoy the technology, or appreciate the convenience of charging at home.


There's nothing wrong with being enthusiastic about a purchase- you should have heard me when I bought my new Levante rod and Shimano Stradic reel. But when someone else's decision not to make the same purchase feels like a personal challenge, the conversation has wandered pretty far from the vehicle itself.

And before anyone accuses me of singling out EV enthusiasts, the anti-EV crowd can be just as ridiculous.


I've seen legitimate concerns about vehicle weight, charging infrastructure, and battery safety exaggerated into sweeping claims about collapsing parking garages and infrastructure catastrophe. Those arguments deserve the same skepticism. But the vocal minority who treat their vehicle purchase as evidence of personal enlightenment aren't doing EV adoption any favors.


You bought a car. You didn't achieve a higher state of consciousness.

 

I Tried Being the EV Advocate

My brother visits me on the river on weekends and during school breaks. He's about as laid-back as you can get. This is a guy who rolls out of bed, grabs a cup of coffee, and heads straight down to the dock to fish in his bathrobe. He's even taken the kayak out like that just to see if he could catch a few fish before bothering to get dressed.


He doesn't get worked up about politics, doesn't gossip, and generally minds his own business. He just enjoys life and doesn't worry much about what everybody else is doing. So naturally, I decided he'd be the perfect person to practice my EV sales pitch on.


We were sitting on the dock one afternoon, and I started throwing all the usual EV arguments at him. Lower operating costs, less maintenance, the technology, and how his five-mile commute to work would be an easy fit for an EV.


He mentioned that he didn't want to wait two hours to charge a car. Fair enough, that's a misconception worth correcting. I explained that DC fast charging can be considerably quicker, and he accepted that.

Then he said he didn't want to sit at a charging station for an hour, either.


And here's the thing. He lives in an apartment without EV charging. He can't plug in when he gets home, so he'd have to go somewhere else to charge. That's a real inconvenience, no matter how short his commute is. But I kept going. I even brought up the mining and battery minerals argument, explaining the usual misconceptions about how EV batteries are made and where the materials come from.


He looked at me like I'd lost my damn mind.


He hadn't said a word about mining. He didn't care about lithium, cobalt, or the environmental arguments. I was answering objections he hadn't even raised because I'd heard them debated so many times. Eventually, he just shrugged and said, "I don't know. I just want to drive my car."


And that was pretty much the end of my experiment.


Here's a guy who can spend an entire morning fishing in his bathrobe without giving two shits what anybody thinks. Did I really expect him to suddenly become passionate about battery chemistry and charging infrastructure?


I was the very EV advocate I've been complaining about. Just to test this conversation.


All he wanted was to drive his car.

 

Maybe Not Everybody Needs Convincing

I keep coming back to that conversation with my brother. He wasn't arguing that EVs were bad, and he wasn't trying to prove gasoline-powered vehicles were better. He simply wasn't interested in changing how he drives. And there I was, explaining why he should reconsider.


That's what bothers me about some of these discussions. At some point, sharing information turns into trying to win an argument. When someone still doesn't agree, another statistic comes out, another study, or another country where EV adoption is taking off.


Maybe the person understands everything you've told them. Maybe they've weighed the advantages and disadvantages. Or maybe they just don't care enough about the subject to spend their afternoon debating it. None of those possibilities makes them wrong.


As someone who works in technical training, I know there's a difference between helping people understand their options and trying to convince them to make the decision I would make. Good information matters. So does listening to the answer.


I've driven EVs. I liked the Tesla enough to rent one twice. I might even buy an electric truck someday. But I don't need to be convinced that the technology works, and I don't need somebody else deciding whether my reasons for keeping my Colorado are good enough.


My brother had the whole thing figured out before I started my little experiment. He just wanted to drive his car.


And that's a perfectly reasonable position.


Next in Part 3: What happens when EV advocates spend so much time explaining why people should buy electric vehicles that they stop listening to what those people actually want?

 
 
 

Comments


  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

©2021 by Snarky Solar Guy. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page